| Date | Our Pick | Result |
| May 15 2024 | Colorado Avalanche at Dallas Stars (Dallas Stars -145) | loss |
| May 14 2024 | Boston Bruins at Florida Panthers (Boston Bruins +175) | WINNER |
| May 14 2024 | Vancouver Canucks at Edmonton Oilers (Edmonton Oilers -205) | WINNER |
| May 13 2024 | Carolina Hurricanes at NY Rangers (Carolina Hurricanes -110) | WINNER |
| May 13 2024 | Dallas Stars at Colorado Avalanche (Dallas Stars -105) | WINNER |
| May 12 2024 | Florida Panthers at Boston Bruins (Florida Panthers -169) | WINNER |
| May 12 2024 | Vancouver Canucks at Edmonton Oilers (Edmonton Oilers -204) | loss |
| May 11 2024 | Dallas Stars at Colorado Avalanche (Colorado Avalanche -135) | loss |
| May 11 2024 | NY Rangers at Carolina Hurricanes (Carolina Hurricanes -145) | WINNER |
| May 10 2024 | Edmonton Oilers at Vancouver Canucks (Edmonton Oilers -141) | WINNER |
| May 10 2024 | Florida Panthers at Boston Bruins (Boston Bruins +115) | loss |
| May 9 2024 | Colorado Avalanche at Dallas Stars (Dallas Stars -145) | WINNER |
| May 9 2024 | NY Rangers at Carolina Hurricanes (Carolina Hurricanes -161) | loss |
| May 8 2024 | Boston at Florida (Florida -164) | WINNER |
| May 8 2024 | Edmonton at Vancouver (Vancouver +115) | WINNER |
|