| Date | Our Pick | Result |
| Dec 22 2025 | Columbus at Los Angeles (Los Angeles +145) | loss |
| Dec 22 2025 | Seattle at Anaheim (Seattle +154) | WINNER |
| Dec 22 2025 | St Louis at Tampa Bay (Tampa Bay -495) | WINNER |
| Dec 22 2025 | Vancouver at Philadelphia (Vancouver +122) | loss |
| Dec 21 2025 | Buffalo at New Jersey (New Jersey -155) | loss |
| Dec 21 2025 | Colorado at Minnesota (Minnesota +154) | loss |
| Dec 21 2025 | Montreal at Pittsburgh (Pittsburgh -106) | WINNER |
| Dec 21 2025 | NY Rangers at Nashville (Nashville -105) | WINNER |
| Dec 21 2025 | Ottawa at Boston (Boston +126) | loss |
| Dec 21 2025 | Toronto at Dallas (Dallas -195) | WINNER |
| Dec 21 2025 | Vegas at Edmonton (Edmonton -125) | WINNER |
| Dec 21 2025 | Washington at Detroit (Detroit -115) | WINNER |
| Dec 21 2025 | Winnipeg at Utah (Winnipeg +111) | loss |
| Dec 20 2025 | Carolina at Tampa Bay (Tampa Bay -122) | WINNER |
| Dec 20 2025 | Chicago at Ottawa (Ottawa -262) | WINNER |
|