| Date | Our Pick | Result |
| May 13 2026 | Minnesota at Colorado (Colorado -200) | WINNER |
| May 12 2026 | Anaheim at Vegas (Vegas -147) | WINNER |
| May 12 2026 | Buffalo at Montreal (Buffalo +123) | WINNER |
| May 11 2026 | Colorado at Minnesota (Colorado -133) | WINNER |
| May 10 2026 | Buffalo at Montreal (Montreal -119) | WINNER |
| May 10 2026 | Vegas at Anaheim (Anaheim +102) | WINNER |
| May 9 2026 | Carolina at Philadelphia (Carolina -182) | WINNER |
| May 9 2026 | Colorado at Minnesota (Minnesota +118) | WINNER |
| May 8 2026 | Montreal at Buffalo (Buffalo -126) | loss |
| May 8 2026 | Vegas at Anaheim (Vegas -110) | WINNER |
| May 7 2026 | Carolina at Philadelphia (Carolina -157) | WINNER |
| May 6 2026 | Anaheim at Vegas (Vegas -153) | loss |
| May 6 2026 | Montreal at Buffalo (Montreal +114) | loss |
| May 5 2026 | Minnesota at Colorado (Colorado -190) | WINNER |
| May 4 2026 | Anaheim at Vegas (Anaheim +146) | loss |
|