| Date | Our Pick | Result |
| May 7 2024 | Carolina at NY Rangers (NY Rangers -105) | WINNER |
| May 7 2024 | Colorado at Dallas (Colorado +105) | WINNER |
| May 6 2024 | Boston at Florida (Florida -164) | loss |
| May 5 2024 | Carolina at NY Rangers (NY Rangers -110) | WINNER |
| May 5 2024 | Vegas at Dallas (Dallas -155) | WINNER |
| May 4 2024 | Toronto at Boston (Boston -130) | WINNER |
| May 3 2024 | Dallas at Vegas (Vegas -110) | WINNER |
| May 3 2024 | Vancouver at Nashville (Vancouver +105) | WINNER |
| May 2 2024 | Boston at Toronto (Boston -130) | loss |
| May 1 2024 | Los Angeles at Edmonton (Edmonton -196) | WINNER |
| May 1 2024 | Vegas at Dallas (Dallas -161) | WINNER |
| Apr 30 2024 | Colorado at Winnipeg (Colorado -115) | WINNER |
| Apr 30 2024 | Nashville at Vancouver (Nashville +110) | WINNER |
| Apr 30 2024 | NY Islanders at Carolina (Carolina -270) | WINNER |
| Apr 30 2024 | Toronto at Boston (Boston -175) | loss |
|